How Do You Spot a Bad AEO or GEO Agency Proposal?
Look for guarantees, secret methods, and reporting that never connects to revenue. A good proposal names the prompts it targets, explains how it measures results, and lists what you get each month.
By Steve Merrill · November 18, 2026
AEO (answer engine optimization) and GEO (generative engine optimization) are new enough that anyone can put them on a pitch deck. Here are seven red flags I would check for before signing anything.
1. A Guarantee of Rankings or AI Citations
No agency controls what an AI assistant says. Google’s own documentation on AI features in Search says there are no special requirements to appear in them beyond the normal fundamentals. If the proposal promises a number of citations by a date, the promise is the problem.
2. No Explanation of How Results Are Measured
The same prompt can return different answers on different runs. A serious proposal says which prompts it tracks, which assistants it tests, and how many times it runs each one. If you hear “we monitor your AI visibility” and nothing more, ask for the method in writing.
3. A Secret AI Algorithm Instead of Documented Crawlers
The basics are public. OpenAI documents its crawlers and user agents, and Perplexity publishes its own bot documentation. An agency that talks about a proprietary method but cannot say whether those bots can reach your site has skipped the first step.
4. Schema Markup as the Entire Deliverable
Structured data matters. Schema.org’s Product type is a good example of what machines can read about your catalog. But markup alone does not make anyone cite you, so a proposal that is only “we will add schema” is thin.
5. No Knowledge of Your Ecommerce Platform
Platform details decide what is possible. On Shopify, that means themes, product data, apps, and what the Shopify Help Center says you can and cannot edit. If the proposal never mentions your platform by name, it is a generic template with your logo on it.
6. Mentions Reported With No Link to Traffic or Revenue
A screenshot of your brand name inside an AI answer feels good. It does not tell you whether anyone clicked or bought. Ask how AI referrals will show up in your analytics and which sales they connect to.
7. A Long Contract With a Vague Scope
Twelve months, one flat fee, and a line that says “ongoing optimization.” That is a lot of trust for a field this new. Ask for a deliverables list by month and an exit clause after the first 90 days.
What a Good Proposal Looks Like
It is boring and specific. It names the prompts your customers actually ask, such as “best waterproof hiking boots for wide feet,” and says which pages will be changed to answer them.
It lists what you get each month. It says how success is measured, who checks the numbers, and what happens if the first 90 days show nothing.
Read that again. A proposal that reads like a brochure is one. A proposal that reads like a work order is something you can hold someone to.
Questions to Ask in the Sales Call
Ask which five prompts they would target for your store first, and why those five. Ask for a sample report from an anonymized client, with the method written next to the numbers.
Ask what they would not do. An agency that cannot name a limit has not thought hard about the work.
How We Chose This List
These flags come from the questions I would ask any vendor before paying them: can they prove it, can they explain it, and can I leave. The same checks apply to WRKNG Digital, which builds AI visibility tools for Shopify stores and is one option among many. Hold every agency to the same standard.
FAQ
Q: What is the biggest red flag in an AEO agency proposal?
A guarantee of AI citations or rankings. No agency controls what ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity says, so a guarantee means the agency is either overselling or not telling you how it works.
Q: Is AEO different from GEO?
In practice the terms describe the same work: making your content easy for AI systems to find, understand, and cite. Judge a proposal on its deliverables, not on which acronym it uses.
Q: What should an AEO proposal include?
A named list of target prompts, a stated method for measuring citations, a deliverables list with dates, and a clear exit clause. If any of those is missing, ask for it before signing.
Q: Can I do AEO myself instead of hiring an agency?
Yes, for the fundamentals. Allowing AI crawlers, adding accurate structured data, and writing direct answers to customer questions are all documented by Google, OpenAI, and Perplexity.
Want a second opinion on a proposal, or to see where your store stands with AI shopping assistants? Start here with WRKNG Digital.
