By Steve Merrill · November 13, 2026
Which AEO agency should a SaaS company hire?
Hire the agency that can show you how it measures AI mentions and citations, knows your product category, and promises work instead of rankings. A polished portfolio is the weakest signal of the three.
I have sat through a lot of agency pitches. The best-looking decks rarely matched the work that followed. These six criteria are what I would check first.
Portfolios show what an agency chose to publish. They do not show how the work was measured, who did it, or whether it would transfer to your product. The criteria below test the method instead.
1. They show how they measure AI mentions and citations
Ask for the prompt list, the AI engines tested, and how often the scan is re-run. AI answers change from one run to the next, so a single screenshot proves nothing. A real agency reports mention rate and citation rate across a fixed prompt set over time.
2. They understand your product category
SaaS buyers ask AI questions like "best project management tool for agencies" or "[tool] vs [tool] for a 20-person team." Ask the agency to write five prompts your buyers would type. If the list is generic, they have not done the work.
3. They fix crawl access and structured data first
If AI crawlers cannot read your pages, nothing else matters. OpenAI documents its crawlers, including OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot in its bots documentation, and Perplexity publishes the same for PerplexityBot. Your agency should check robots.txt, page rendering, and structured data as described by Google Search Central before writing a single article.
4. They build comparison and integration content
SaaS decisions run through comparison pages, "alternatives to" pages, integration pages, and plain-language pricing explainers. Ask who writes them and who checks them for accuracy. A generalist writer guessing at your feature set will hurt you.
5. They work on sources outside your website
In the prompt scans we run, AI answers often name sources other than the brand's own site: review platforms, forums, and third-party roundups. Ask which outside sources the agency would target for you and how it earns those placements. "We will do outreach" is not an answer.
6. They tell you what they will not promise
Nobody controls what an AI model says. Any agency that guarantees placement in ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity answers is selling you something it cannot deliver. Good agencies promise specific deliverables and a reporting cadence, and they say so up front.
Where WRKNG Digital fits
I run WRKNG Digital. Our work is built around ecommerce, mostly Shopify stores, so we are not the obvious pick for a pure B2B SaaS product. If your company sells through a storefront, the criteria above are the ones we hold ourselves to. If not, use the same six questions on whoever you interview, including us. Compare the answers side by side and pick the team that can explain its method in plain language.
How we chose these criteria
We picked criteria you can verify in a single sales call. Each one can be tested by asking for a document, a sample, or a straight answer. Portfolios are curated by the agency. Methods and reports are harder to fake. Anything that cannot be checked in the first call did not make the list.
For background on how structured data is read, see the FAQPage definition on schema.org. For how an online store's pages get found in general, Shopify Help Center covers SEO basics.
FAQ
How long does AEO take to show results for a SaaS company?
Technical fixes can be picked up by AI crawlers within weeks. Changes in how often AI assistants mention your brand usually take a few months of consistent publishing and measurement. Any agency quoting an exact date is guessing.
Is AEO different from SEO for SaaS?
They share a foundation: crawlable pages, clear structure, and trusted content. AEO adds a focus on being named and cited inside AI-written answers, which means measuring mentions instead of only rankings.
Should a SaaS company hire an agency or do AEO in-house?
In-house works if you have a writer who knows the product and someone to own measurement and technical fixes. An agency makes sense when you lack that capacity or want an outside baseline.
What should an AEO agency report every month?
A fixed prompt list, the AI engines tested, your mention rate and citation rate, the competitors named instead of you, and the pages shipped that month.
Do I need a different AEO agency for B2B SaaS than for ecommerce?
Not always, but check category fit. B2B SaaS prompts lean on comparisons, integrations, and use cases, while ecommerce prompts lean on products, reviews, and availability. Ask for work in a situation close to yours.
Want to see how AI assistants currently describe your store? Start with the WRKNG Digital agentic commerce page.

