7 Things to Compare Before Choosing an AEO or GEO Agency for Your Ecommerce Brand

November 16, 2026

How Do You Choose the Best AEO or GEO Agency for an Ecommerce Brand?

Compare agencies on seven things: ecommerce platform depth, measurement method, technical fixes, product data work, citable content, honest claims, and scope. An agency that is strong on all seven will show you the work. An agency that is weak on any of them will show you a slide deck.

By Steve Merrill · November 16, 2026

Most ecommerce owners I talk to have already been pitched by two or three agencies selling "AI visibility." The pitches sound the same. The work behind them does not.

I spent more than $5 million of my own money on Facebook ads for my clothing brand. I learned fast to ask what a vendor will actually do on Monday morning. Ask the same thing here.

1. Ecommerce Platform Depth

Ask which platform the agency works on every week. Shopify, BigCommerce, and WooCommerce each handle themes, apps, and crawler rules differently. On Shopify, for example, robots.txt is edited through a template file described in the Shopify Help Center, and an agency that has not done it will not know the limits. Ask for two or three live stores they have worked on, with the client names removed if needed.

2. A Repeatable Measurement Method

Because AI answers change from run to run, a real agency tests a fixed set of buyer prompts several times, records brand mentions and citations, and repeats the test on a schedule. If they cannot show you a baseline, they cannot show you progress. Ask which assistants they test and how many runs they average.

3. Technical Fixes for AI Crawlers and Structured Data

Check that they audit crawler access for OpenAI and Perplexity, which each publish their bot details in the OpenAI crawler documentation and the Perplexity bot documentation. They should also validate structured data against Google Search Central guidance. Blocked bots and broken markup are the cheapest problems to fix, so they should be fixed first.

4. Product Data and Catalog Work

Ecommerce visibility lives in the catalog, so ask whether they clean up titles, descriptions, attributes, and Product markup using the schema.org Product vocabulary. An agency that only writes blog posts is skipping the pages that actually sell.

5. Content Built to Be Cited

Ask to see a real page they wrote and what makes it quotable. Good pages answer a question in the first two sentences, name their sources, and stay specific. Padded 3,000-word articles are a red flag.

6. Honest Claims About Results

Nobody controls what an AI assistant says. Walk away from any agency that guarantees citations or rankings in ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity. Look for agencies that promise deliverables and measurement instead, and anonymize or explain any case study they show you.

7. Scope, Ownership, and Pricing Clarity

Get a written list of what ships each month and who owns the content, markup, and reports afterward. Ask what happens when the contract ends. Vague retainers hide thin work, and a clear monthly scope is the easiest thing to compare across proposals.

A Quick Scorecard

Score each agency from 0 to 2 on every item above. Zero means no answer, one means a vague answer, two means they showed you proof. Anything under 10 out of 14 is a pass.

How We Chose This List

These seven criteria come from what I see ecommerce owners get wrong when they hire for a new channel, and they apply to any agency, including ours. At WRKNG Digital, we build AI marketing tools for Shopify stores and we do not promise specific results. We promise what our team will actually do. Hold us to the same seven questions as everyone else.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between AEO and GEO?

AEO (answer engine optimization) and GEO (generative engine optimization) both aim to get your brand mentioned and cited in AI-generated answers. Agencies use the terms almost interchangeably, so judge them by the work they do, not the label.

Q: How long does AEO or GEO take to show results?

Technical fixes like crawler access and structured data can be live within days. Changes in how often AI assistants mention your brand usually take weeks to show up and vary by prompt, so ask for a baseline and a re-test schedule.

Q: Should an AEO agency guarantee AI citations?

No. AI answers change from run to run and no agency controls them. A trustworthy agency promises specific deliverables and measurement, not guaranteed placement.

Q: Do I need a specialist agency or can my SEO agency handle it?

Some SEO agencies handle it well. Ask them the same seven questions in this list. If they cannot explain how they measure AI mentions and fix product data, keep looking.

Want to see how your store shows up in AI shopping answers today? Start with WRKNG Digital’s agentic commerce page.

Back to Blog