What should you ask a Shopify ads and email agency before you sign?
Ask seven things: who owns the accounts, how results are reported, which attribution model is used, how the agency gets paid, what the exit terms are, who does the work, and what happens in the first 90 days. The best Shopify agencies for ads and email answer all seven in writing before you pay a dollar.
By Steve Merrill · November 16, 2026
We ranked agencies in 8 Best Shopify Agencies for Ads and Email Marketing in 2026. A ranking tells you who to talk to. This checklist tells you what to ask once you're on the call.
Most bad agency deals don't fail on day one. They fail in month four, when the numbers look good in one dashboard and flat in your bank account. These questions surface that gap early, while you can still negotiate.
1. Who owns the ad accounts, email platform and customer data?
You should own the Meta ad account, the Google Ads account, the Shopify store and the email platform. The agency gets access through a partner connection or a Shopify staff account. If the agency owns the accounts, you can't leave without losing your audiences, flows and history.
2. Which numbers will you report, and where do they come from?
Ask for a sample report before you sign. Platform numbers are fine, but they should sit next to your Shopify revenue, not replace it. Shopify's marketing reports give you a cross-check the agency doesn't control.
3. Which attribution model do you use, and what happens when platforms disagree?
Meta and Google will both claim credit for the same order, because each counts conversions its own way. Google's Ads Help documents how its attribution models assign credit, and Meta's attribution settings change reported results too. Ask which model and window the agency reports on, and ask for one blended number: total revenue divided by total ad spend.
4. How are you paid, and what does that reward?
A percent-of-spend fee pays the agency more when your budget goes up, whether or not profit does. A percent of email revenue can pay on orders that would have happened anyway, like repeat buyers. Ask what a flat retainer would cost instead, and what the fee does if spend doubles.
5. What do the term, notice and exit clauses say?
Read the minimum term, the notice period and the auto-renewal clause. In my experience, three to six month minimums are common, and that's fine if you have a clean way out after. Get it in writing that creative, email templates and flow builds are yours when you leave.
6. Who does the work, and how often will we talk?
Ask who will actually run your account, not who is on the sales call. Get names, roles and how many other accounts each person manages. A weekly written update and a monthly strategy call is a reasonable starting cadence.
7. What will ads and email do together in the first 90 days?
Good agencies plan both channels as one system. Ads bring in first-time buyers, and flows like welcome, abandoned cart and post-purchase turn them into repeat customers. Ask for a written 90-day plan with the tests they'll run and the metrics that decide whether you continue.
How We Chose These Questions
I've spent over $5 million of my own money on Facebook ads and ran a $10 million a year ecommerce brand, so I've been the client signing these contracts. Each question targets a spot where agency and client interests can split: access, proof, credit, pay and exit. A good agency won't mind any of them. A vague answer to one is worth noting before you sign. WRKNG Digital is an agency too, so we have a stake. Ask us all seven.
FAQ
How long should a Shopify ads and email agency contract be?
Short enough that you can leave if it isn't working. An initial term of three to six months is a common ask, so negotiate month-to-month after that and a 30-day notice period.
Should I pay my agency a percentage of ad spend?
It's common, but it pays the agency more when your budget grows, whether or not profit does. A flat retainer, or a fee tied to a profit baseline you both agree on, lines incentives up better.
What should an ads and email agency report every month?
Total revenue, total ad spend, blended return (revenue divided by spend), new versus returning customer revenue, and email's share of total revenue. Shopify's numbers should sit next to the platform numbers.
Can I run a trial before committing to an agency?
Ask for it. Many agencies will agree to a short paid test or a 90-day initial term if you define the success metrics in writing before it starts.
Shoppers now ask AI assistants what to buy before they ever see an ad. If you want to know how your store shows up there, see what we're building for Shopify stores.

