5 Questions to Ask Before You Choose a GEO Agency

November 19, 2026

By Steve Merrill · November 19, 2026

How Do You Choose a GEO Agency?

Choose a GEO agency by asking how they measure AI visibility, what they will change on your site, and what they refuse to promise. The best agencies answer all three in plain language and show you a sample report before you sign.

GEO (generative engine optimization) is young, and a lot of agencies renamed their SEO packages overnight. I have read pitch decks that promised "AI rankings." There is no ranking to guarantee. Use these five questions to cut through that.

Ask them in order. By question three you will know whether you are talking to an operator or a salesperson.

1. How do you measure whether AI assistants mention and cite my brand?

Ask for a specific method: a fixed set of prompts, run on a schedule, across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity, with mentions and citations logged separately. Answers from AI tools change between runs, so a single screenshot proves nothing. If they cannot show you a baseline before work starts, they cannot show you progress after.

2. What exactly will you change on my site and in my content?

A good answer names deliverables: rewritten pages that open with a direct answer, a FAQ section on key pages, product and organization data cleaned up, and new content for the questions buyers ask. A weak answer says "optimize for AI" and stops there. Ask for a sample page they have restructured and read it yourself.

3. What can you not promise, and why?

Nobody controls what ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity says on a given day. Google's own Search Central documentation frames AI features in Search around the same foundations as normal search: helpful, crawlable, accurate content. An agency that guarantees citations is selling you a story.

4. How do you handle structured data and crawler access?

The basics are not glamorous. Pages need to be reachable by the crawlers that feed AI products, and key facts should be marked up with Schema.org types such as Product, Organization, and FAQPage. OpenAI's help center and Perplexity's documentation are where you check what each company says about how its products find and use web content.

5. Who does the work, and what do I own when we stop?

Ask who writes the content, who edits it, and who touches your site. Then ask what you keep: the pages, the schema, the prompt list, and the tracking data should all be yours. If the reports live only in their dashboard, you are renting your own visibility.

Red Flags to Watch For

Walk away from guaranteed citations, fixed ranking claims, and pricing that has no link to scope. Be careful with long contracts signed before any baseline report exists. Be careful with vague reporting too. If every answer comes back as "our proprietary system," you are being asked to trust, not verify.

Good agencies get more specific when you push. Bad ones get more abstract.

How We Chose These Questions

Each question tests one thing: whether the agency can measure, execute, stay honest, handle the technical basics, and leave you with assets. I wrote them from the angle of a store owner who has to defend the spend to a partner or a bank, because that is the person who gets burned when an agency overpromises.

Where WRKNG Digital Fits

We are one option, not the only one. We build AI visibility work for ecommerce brands, and we do not promise specific results. We promise what our team will do, and we are happy to be held to these same five questions. Compare us against at least two other agencies, and weigh the answers, not the pitch. You can see how we approach it here.

FAQ

Q: What is a GEO agency?

A GEO (generative engine optimization) agency works to make your brand show up in answers from AI assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. The work overlaps with SEO but adds answer-focused content, structured data, and citation tracking.

Q: Can a GEO agency guarantee I will be cited by ChatGPT or Gemini?

No. AI answers vary from run to run, and no agency controls them. A trustworthy agency promises specific work and honest measurement, not placement.

Q: Is GEO different from SEO?

They share a foundation of crawlable, accurate, useful pages. GEO adds a focus on how AI systems quote and cite sources, so the writing format and measurement change.

Q: How long does GEO work take to show results?

Expect to see early movement in tracked prompts over weeks, not days. Anyone quoting a fixed timeline is guessing.

Q: What should I ask for in a first meeting?

Ask for a sample report, a sample rewritten page, and a plain description of what you will own at the end. Those three items tell you more than any pitch deck.

Ready to see where your store stands in AI answers? Start with the WRKNG Digital agentic commerce page.

Back to Blog